********
10/24/2024
Open
Personal Injury and Torts - Motor Vehicle
Street near Interstate 95 in Duval County, Florida. AN UNKNOWN EMPLOYEE/AGENT, entered into Plaintiff, CYNTHIA KELLY's lane, causing a collision with Plaintiff, CYNTHIA KELLY's, vehicle.
5. At all times material to this action, the subject truck driven by AN UNKNOWN EMPLOYEE/AGENT, was a commercial motor vehicle and subject to regulations promulgated by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA).
6. The incident giving rise to this action occurred in Duval County, Florida.
7. Venue is proper in this Court pursuant to F.S.A. 47.051.
The Plaintiff realleges and incorporates the allegations of paragraphs 1 through 8 above and further alleges:
8. On July 6, 2023 , Plaintiff, CYNTHIA KELLY's, traveling eastbound on Emerson Street near Interstate 95 in Duval County, Florida
9. At that time and place, AN UNKNOWN EMPLOYEE/AGENT, was operating a tractor-trailer owned by Defendant, BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS, while in the course and scope of employment with BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS and traveling eastbound on Emerson Street near Interstate 95 in Duval County, Florida. AN UNKNOWN EMPLOYEE/AGENT, entered into Plaintiff, CYNTHIA KELLY's lane, causing a collision with Plaintiff, CYNTHIA KELLY's, vehicle.
Plaintiff, CYNTHIA KELLY, realleges and incorporates by reference each and every allegation contained in Paragraphs 1 through 9 above and further alleges:
Page 210. At the and place of the aforementioned incident, AN UNKNOWN EMPLOYEE/AGENT, was operating the vehicle during the course and scope of their employment with Defendant, BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS.
11. At that time and place, AN UNKNOWN EMPLOYEE/AGENT, was operating and driving the vehicle with the permission and consent of its owner, Defendant, BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS.
12. At all relevant times, AN UNKNOWN EMPLOYEE/AGENT, was the employee, agent, servant, and/or statutory employee for Defendant, BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS, operating for the benefit of, in furtherance of the interests of and/or within the course and scope of his employment with Defendant, BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS. Accordingly, Defendant, HICKMAN TRANSPORT CO INC, is vicariously liable for the acts of AN UNKNOWN EMPLOYEE/AGENT. Regardless of the employment or agency relationship, Defendant, BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS, is an interstate motor carrier responsible for the acts of AN UNKNOWN EMPLOYEE/AGENT.
13. Defendant, BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS, is vicariously liable for the negligence of AN UNKNOWN EMPLOYEE/AGENT, pursuant to the Florida Dangerous Instrumentality Doctrine.
14. As a direct and proximate cause of Defendant, BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS's negligence, Plaintiff, CYNTHIA KELLY, suffered or incurred significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function and/or permanent and significant scarring; permanent injury within a reasonable degree of medical probability other than scarring or disfigurement; aggravation or activation of an existing disease or physical defect; pain, suffering, disability, physical impairment, mental anguish, inconvenience, and a loss of capacity for the enjoyment of life; expenses of
Page 3Judge
DEES, ROBERT M
Plaintiff
CYNTHIA KELLY
Defendants
BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS DBA BIG CITY ACCESS BRANDSAFWAY SAFWAY
DAVID DIAZ
Plaintiff Attorneys
Mims, Chelsea Ellis
Lonker, Whitney Rae
Defendant Attorneys
Bridge, Steven Thomas II
Harken, Nicholas David
9/29/2025- D53- NOTICE OF HEARING ON 11/13/2025 @930AM VIA ZOOM
9/22/2025- D52- ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES (DEFT., BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS DBA BIG CITY ACCESS BRANDSAFWAY) TO PLTF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT
9/9/2025- D49- SUMMONS ISSUED DIAZ, DAVID (DEFENDANT)
9/10/2025- D50- CASE FEES PAID: $10.00 ON RECEIPT NUMBER 4967506
9/16/2025- D51- MEDIATION DISPOSITION REPORT - NO AGREEMENT REACHED
8/31/2025- D47- ORDER FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT
8/25/2025- D46- NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION (DEFT BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS D/B/A BIG CITY ACCESS BRANDSAFWAY SAFWAYNOTICE OF CONTINUED VIDEOTAPED/ OF CYNTHIA KELLY @1000AM ON 08/29/2025
8/22/2025- D45- MOTION TO COMPEL (PLAINTIFF'S SECOND) COMPLETE RESPONSES TO THIRD REQEUSTS TO PRODUCE
9/2/2025- D48- AMENDED COMPLAINT - PLTF
HearingTime: 9:30 AM; Type: JURY TRIAL; Location: NO COURT ROOM ENTERED; Courtroom: 0
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 10/1/2025; SUMMONS RETURNED INDICATING SERVICE ON DAVID DIAZ @645PM ON 09/26/2025 BY IDA HOLT
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 9/30/2025; NOTICE OF HEARING ON 11/13/2025 @930AM VIA ZOOM
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 9/23/2025; ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES (DEFT., BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS DBA BIG CITY ACCESS BRANDSAFWAY) TO PLTF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 9/16/2025; MEDIATION DISPOSITION REPORT - NO AGREEMENT REACHED
[-] Read LessFinancialDescription: SUMMONS($10/ea) 07/01/2023 (Circuit); Assessed: $10.00; Paid: $10.00; Balance: $0.00
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 9/10/2025; CASE FEES PAID: $10.00 ON RECEIPT NUMBER 4967506
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 9/10/2025; SUMMONS ISSUED DIAZ, DAVID (DEFENDANT)
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 9/3/2025; AMENDED COMPLAINT - PLTF
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 9/2/2025; ORDER FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT
[-] Read LessFinancialDescription: SUMMONS($10/ea) 07/01/2023 (Circuit); Assessed: $10.00; Paid: $10.00; Balance: $0.00
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 10/24/2024; ORDER SETTING CASE MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR NON-COMPLEX CASES
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 10/24/2024; CASE FEES PAID: $411.00 ON RECEIPT NUMBER 4752722
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 10/24/2024; REQUEST TO PRODUCE (PLTFS FIRST) TO DEFT
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 10/24/2024; NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES (PLTFS) TO DEFT
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 10/24/2024; SUMMONS ISSUED TO BRANDSAFWAY SOLUTIONS DBA BIG CITY ACCESS BRANDSAFWAY SAFWAY
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 10/24/2024; COMPLAINT
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 10/24/2024; REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS (PLTFS) TO DEFT
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 10/24/2024; COVER SHEET
[-] Read LessDocketEntered: 10/24/2024; AUTO NEGLIGENCE CASE
[-] Read Less